SeriousBest practice
tabindexPositive tabindex changes the tab order
tabindex="1" or higher forces an element to the front of the keyboard order, so focus jumps around the page. Use tabindex="0" or nothing, and order the HTML the way people read it.
Who it hurts
Keyboard users and screen reader users.
Usually added to “help” a search box or form. It breaks the order everywhere else.
How to fix it
Pick your stack. Review every change before you ship it.
Before
<input type="search" tabindex="1">After
<input type="search">Check it by hand too
Tab through the whole page. Focus should follow the reading order without jumping back.
Automated checks find a large share of accessibility problems, but not all of them. Passing this check does not on its own make a page compliant.